S'inscrireSe connecter

Eternaltwin

Hosting vendor analysis

Introduction

This document contains an evaluation of current hosting vendors with their offers. The goal is to select the hosting vendor we'll use in 2025.

Current subscription

We currently use OVH for hosting, with the following offer:

  • Name: RISE-LE-2 2021
  • Gross price: 926.50€/year (77.21€/month)
  • CPU: Intel Xeon-E 2274G - 4c/8t - 4 GHz/4.9 GHz
  • RAM: 64 GiB ECC 2666 MHz
    • Usage: medium, about 20%
  • Storage: 2×960 GiB SSD NVMe
    • SAMSUNG MZQLB960HAJR-00007
    • Raid 1
    • Usage: about 350GiB
      • 250GiB for the Postgres DB
      • 50GiB for Clickhouse (logs, traces, metrics)
      • 50GiB for applications
  • Network:
    • Usage:
      • up: 16Mib/s up = 2MiB/s
      • down: 1Mib/s = 0.125MiB/s
  • Region: Europe (France - Roubaix)
  • OS: Linux 6.10 (Arch)

We subscribed on 2021-12-14 for one year. We then renewed twice for a duration of a year each time:

  • 2021-12-14: 842.27€/year (70.19€/month)
  • 2022-12-14: 926.50€/year (77.21€/month)
  • 2023-12-14: 926.50€/year (77.21€/month)

The current subscription expires on 2024-12-14.

Requirements

  • CPU: We need a stronger CPU, this is the current bottleneck for the server.
  • RAM: 64GiB seems good enough currently, 128GiB would be nice to have but not required
  • Storage: Having 1TiB available currently seems good enough, 2TiB would be nice to have some headroom as we add more games
  • Network: This should not be a bottleneck
  • Region: Europe, most of our users are in Europe
  • Extra: we don't need much extra support, we are able to manage everything ourselves.
  • Budget: let's keep it below 100€/month if possible

Offers

The main vendors compared were OVH and Hetzner as they are reliable vendors with good prices.

OVH RISE-2 2024

  • https://www.ovhcloud.com/fr/bare-metal/rise/rise-2/
  • 889.20/year (74.10€/month)
  • CPU: Intel Xeon-E 2388G - 8c/16t - 3.2GHz/4.6GHz
  • RAM: 64GiB
  • Storage: 2×512GB SSD NVMe Soft RAID
  • Out of stock

OVH RISE-Game-1 2024

  • https://www.ovhcloud.com/fr/bare-metal/rise/rise-game-1/
  • 1025.88/year (85.49€/month)
  • CPU: AMD Ryzen 5 5600X - 6c/12t - 3.7GHz/4.6GHz
  • RAM: 32GiB
  • Storage: 2×512GB SSD NVMe Soft RAID

OVH RISE-3 2024

OVH Advance-1 2024

OVH Advance-2 2024

Hetzner AX42 2024

Hetzner AX52 2024

Hetzner EX101 2024

Hetzner AX102 2024

Scaleway Pro-7-M

  • https://www.scaleway.com/en/pricing/dedibox/#pro-range
  • 1199.88€/year (99.99€/month)
  • CPU: Intel Xeon E-2246G 6c/12t - 3.6GHz
  • RAM: 64GiB
  • Storage: 2×960GB SSD NVMe Soft RAID

Scaleway Pro-9-M

  • https://www.scaleway.com/en/pricing/dedibox/#pro-range
  • 1919.88€/year (159.99€/month)
  • CPU: AMD EPYC 7272 12c/24t - 2.9GHz
  • RAM: 128GiB
  • Storage: 2×1TB SSD NVMe Soft RAID

Scaleway Core-10-XS

  • https://www.scaleway.com/en/pricing/dedibox/#core-range
  • 1439.88€/year (119.99€/month)
  • CPU: AMD EPYC 8024P 8c/12t - 2.4GHz
  • RAM: 64GiB
  • Storage: 2×960GB SSD NVMe Soft RAID

Scaleway Aluminium EM-A410X-SSD

  • https://www.scaleway.com/en/elastic-metal/aluminium/
  • 659.88€/year (54.99€/month)
  • CPU: 1x Intel Xeon E5 1650 6c/12t - 3.2GHz
  • RAM: 64GiB
  • Storage: 2×960GB SSD NVMe Soft RAID

Hetzner colocation 14 units - 1/3 Rack

  • https://www.hetzner.com/colocation/13-rack/
  • starting from 1547.00€/year (128.91€/month)
  • We would have to supply our own hardware. a 3k€ server for ~3 years would be amortized by adding ~84€/month

Current conclusion

  • Hetzner has by far the best perf/price ratio.
  • Hetzner AX52 (~700€) would be a nice improvement over the current server, at roughly a similar price. It would probably still be limited to supported expanded games.
  • Hetzner EX101 (~1270€) is in an awkward spot, it uses the CPU that had thermal issues and has to run slower
  • Hetzner AX102 (~1550€) is a strong contender if we want to raise in tier; we could afford it if it let's us merge hosting costs with MyHordes (currently paid independently)